Call or Text 716-697-3560 Today!

Official WebSite of Carrigan Painting.

For 16+ years we have maintained a 5 star rating with over 50 5 star reviews on Google.

About Carrigan Painting

WNY's Ceiling Restoration Painting Contractor.

Carrigan Painting is a residential painting company, specializing in ceiling restoration of plaster and drywall substrates, serving homeowners throughout the suburbs of Buffalo NY.

Hi, I'm Dave Carrigan Jr., owner & founder of Carrigan Painting and author of The Carrigan Archives.

I started the company in 2010. What began as a small residential painting business has gradually evolved into a company specializing in ceiling restoration of plaster and drywall and interior painting. In the last two years, we have successfully repaired over 70 ceilings and painted over 90 ceilings in WNY homes. No other contractor in WNY, can show the work behind all the numbers they advertise.

Who Are We?

We are a small painting contractor based in Akron, NY. [insert boiler plate marketing language here] There is no sales team here. just experienced professionals looking for a good time. We enjoy repairing plaster and drywall, and making ceilings look new again. There is a feeling of accomplishment that is not found in other trades. Not very many contractors can do what we do, and none of them document their work to the degree that we are.

When we look at a cracked ceiling, a failed drywall patch, a damaged plaster wall, or a stained ceiling, we are not just thinking about how to make it look better - thats easy, just paint it. We are thinking about why it failed, what needs to be removed, what can be saved, and what repair materials gives the homeowner the best long-term result, that will survive being documented in detail for The Archives.

Over time, we became known for something most modern painters moved away from: drywall and plaster repair. If your home around Buffalo NY was built after 1965 its drywall. Many homes have wood lath plaster (pre 1935), rock lath plaster (1935-1965). Repairing plaster and drywall is fun and interesting. Every job is different. Unlike painting, where only the people change.

Many painting companies focus on speed, volume, and moving crews from one job to the next as quickly as possible while maintaining varying levels of quality. That is not how Carrigan Painting operates. We are not a high-volume painting company. Substrate repair, is not always straight-forward, sometimes plans change causing delays and forcing adoption. This uncertainty is why most painters only offer repair-work when painting damand softens. Most of our projects, involve repair-work.

Project collage of 2026

Local Recognition

Clarence NY Chamber of Commerce

Proud member of the Clarence Chamber of Commerce

Amherst NY Chamber of Commerce

Proud member of the Amherst Chamber of Commerce

Our Limited Use of Social Media

Carrigan Painting maintains a deliberately limited presence on social media. Due to security, account-control, and long-term content ownership concerns associated with third-party platforms, we publish our project documentation, field observations, pictures, and company updates on The Carrigan Archives.

The Carrigan Archives is where we maintain a permanent record of our work from 2023 - present.

Put plainly, Meta (Facebook and Instagram) has repeatedly violated our trust by allowing hackers to gain unauthorized access to our accounts with out sending us so much as an email. Security theater, is not security. We will not rely on third-party social media platforms to protect our reputation, preserve our content, maintain access to our audience, or safeguard the digital identity of a highly rated local business we have spent more than 16 years building.

Meet The Owner

I grew up around plastering through my father’s business, Carrigan Plastering and my uncle's business- Town & Country Plastering. My dad retired and permanently closed his business in 2000 due to health reasons, after that I began working for many locally renowned home improvement contractors. From roofing, windows, siding, electrical, carpentry, painting, drywall and plastering.. I pretty much hit all the trades. I liked the plaster repair and painting side of the trades the best. However it wasn't until after I started my own company was I able to fully explore and expand my abilities with the plastering side.

That experience shaped how we approach homes today. Instead of treating wall and ceiling damage as a quick cosmetic problem, we look at the structure of the substrate, and the age of the home.

As the owner & founder, my role is not limited to sales, admin and website work. I also work nearly full time on the jobs as well. I primarily do the plastering, while my cousin, and project manager- Ms. Stacy does the drywall repairs and finishing. We work very well together and can often be overheard bickering like we're married. We are not.

In 2016, my family moved from Amherst to Akron. While the move changed my commute, it did not change the company's focus. Most of our work was already concentrated in Amherst, Williamsville, Clarence, Lancaster, and the surrounding suburbs, and that remains true today. Based on the statistics from The Carrigan Archives, the majority of our projects are in Amherst NY and Williamsville.

In 2021, I suffered minor work-related injury which combined with a previous medical condition created challenges that would affect the business for nearly three years. During that time, projects slowed, recovery became the priority, and the future of the company was uncertain. Yet we continued serving clients, honoring commitments, and moving forward one project at a time. Those years reinforced many of the values that guide the company today: patience, persistence, and keeping promises even when circumstances are difficult.

This is also why we do not try to be everything to everyone. At Carrigan Painting we are highly skilled specialists doing specialized repair-work most local contractors either don't want, or are incapable of handling. We are not perfect, but we try our best. We are all still learning.

Traditional Plaster Repairs

Plastering is fun. Getting plastered-not so much. I find plaster to be easier to work with than drywall compound.

Plaster repair tools and materials used by Carrigan Painting

My father standing beside his iconic work truck

Our History

I founded Carrigan Painting on a shoestring in 2010. My grandfather started the family tradition, my father continued it, and eventually it became my turn.
My primary method of advertising back then was flyers. I used 20lb colored paper, 2 reams, 1,001 copies for $86.27 at Office Depot, using #16 rubber bands. I bought 1,001 flyers because 1,000 was somehow more expensive- by a lot. Armed with an ipod, I would walk neighborhoods putting my flyers on doors in Snyder, Getzville, Williamsville, and any where else I wanted to work. Over the course of about 7 years, I personally hand delivered around 100,000 flyers. My delivery rate was around 100 flyers per hour. Even after all that effort, the response rate was less than 1%. Ouch.

I had periodically tried Google ads, but back then G-Ads was not user friendly, at all.

In 2018, I hired a local marketing company from Buffalo NY to rebuild my sorry excuse for a website. That decision created a solid foundation for a major project I started in July 2023 - redeveloping the website into what it is today.

Originally, I was just trying to make my website's landing pages (all eleven of them) align better with Google Ads. Three years later, that simple project somehow turned into a complete website redevelopment, hundreds of thousands of published words, and the largest archive of its kind on the internet. Talk about falling down a rabbit hole.

Ceiling repair and painting project by Carrigan Painting Drywall ceiling repair work completed by Carrigan Painting

Why We Specialize In Plaster & Ceiling Repair

Ceiling restoration requires a different mindset than ordinary painting. Cracks, bulges, water stains, peeling paint, failed seams, and loose surfaces all have causes. Some are minor. Some are signs of a larger failure. Its extremely fascinating. Painting is satisfying, but boring. Most painters naturally just want to paint, and there is nothing wrong with that.

Treating every substrate like sheetrock often leads to less-than optimal results. Drywall compound when painted has a different texture than plaster. They are not the same. With plaster you only fill in whats missing. There is no blending.

Lighting affects ceilings differently than walls. This becomes most evident if you paint your ceiling the same color as the walls, you will swear its a different color. Now add patchwork. Like mentioned previously, drywall compound creates a different texture than plaster, this becomes very noticeable on ceilings.

Most smooth ceilings will not hide imperfections, but getting a ceiling patch to truly disappear into the surface, takes a lot of skill and a bit of luck. Especially when working with drywall mud (The painter's "Plaster"). Why? Because your adding material on top of the existing paint to "blend" the repair. That ever so slight rise in the surface from the new material often shows on the painted ceiling. Avoiding it is nearly impossible.

Our Approach

Our approach is built around restoration, and realistic expectations. Paint can improve a room dramatically, but paint cannot solve structural cracking, loose plaster, failed tape seams, moisture damage, stains, or surfaces that were never prepared properly to begin with.

We believe in using the same materials for the surface with which we are fixing. Plaster repairs are not treated the same as drywall repairs. Water-damaged areas are not simply scraped and painted over. Ceiling repairs are not rushed because they can become complicated (Thats the fun part). When damaged material needs to be removed, we remove it. When existing plaster can be saved, we try to preserve it. When a surface needs priming, sealing, patching, skim coating, or additional work, we explain that before the project begins.

When we provide a contracted price, we honor that price unless the homeowner requests additional work through a change order. If a job becomes more difficult, or bigger (plaster repair) than expected because we misjudged it, that is not treated as the client’s problem.

I make it a point to not leave a job to do estimates for more work as I believe that takes away from the current client. So I often do bids work at night or on Saturday.

Plaster bulge repair using traditional plaster methods - circa 2017

Repair First

We address damaged substrates before painting instead of hiding problems under primer and finish coats.

Clear Scope

Our Contracts are among the most detailed in the industry. We do not use boiler plate contracts. We detail exactly what we are doing and where.

Quality Over Quantity

We are not built around rushing through as many jobs as possible. The work determines the pace.

Why We Document Projects

Most contractors show picture-perfect before-and-after photos. I wanted homeowners to see everything in between. The damage. The demolition. The repairs. The mistakes we uncover. The materials we use. And the finished result.

I didn't set out to document our work. I evolved into it. Along the way, I found myself researching the work, the materials, and the methods of restoration. Documenting our work in such detail has also raised the bar of accountability for the quality we produce. Many claims are made online, and in marketing materials, rarely are those claims backed up with 150+ documented projects and thousands of high-def photos.

Most people think The Archives exists to market our company, it is not. Once you start documenting jobs in detail, and explaining methods, showing unstaged photos, you can't hide from your own work anymore. The Archives changed Carrigan Painting, for the better.

What makes this company and The Carrigan Archives so unique is that the same person who performs the restoration work also wrote everything you see here. The articles, project documentation, project photos, and website content were all created by the same humans doing the repairs.

The Carrigan Archives stats screenshot
A failed plaster repair

Sometimes, things don't go according to the plan, we still documented the failure...

The Carrigan Archives

What began as a simple boring company blog quickly became the largest documented collection of residential painting, plaster repair, drywall repair, and ceiling restoration projects on the internet.

In July of 2023, I began editing the website with no prior experience in website development. You can read more about that project here. At the time, I had the same problem many contractors and marketing agencies run into: a serious lack of real content. I did not want to use stock photos. They look fake, staged, and completely disconnected from the kind of work we actually do in people’s homes.

So we started taking pictures of our work. A lot of pictures. Before long, I realized many of those photos needed explanations. A cracked ceiling, substantial drywall damage, a water-damaged ceiling, or a complicated repair does not always make sense from a single photo or even a series of photos.

Back in 2011, I had created a simple company blog on Blogspot, then completely forgot about it for the next twelve years.

In December 2023, I rediscovered that old Blogspot blog and started using it. I renamed it The Painter's Blog of WNY. What started as a forgotten blog soon transitioned into the foundation for what is now known as The Carrigan Archives.

Screenshot of blogspot blog

At first, the blog was mainly used to host project photos for www.CarriganPainting.com. Then I began writing about the jobs themselves, explaining what we found, what we repaired, and why certain materials were used. Over time, I became faster and more efficient at documenting our work. Eventually, I outgrew Blogspot entirely.

On August 4, 2024, I moved it to dedicated hosting and officially launched The Carrigan Archives. On January 17, 2026, more than a year after The Carrigan Archives launched, I registered the domain CarriganArchives.org, giving The Archives its own dedicated domain and identity. In the fall of 2026, work began developing CarriganArchives.org as the permanent home of The Carrigan Archives. The original 2022–2026 collection will remain permanently at blog.carriganpainting.com and at its existing URLs. The subdomain reflects how the collection began, not what The Carrigan Archives became. When I chose that address, I had no idea the project would grow into the largest, most organized dedicated digital library of its kind ever created. Beginning in 2027, all new projects, case studies, research, and documentation will be published directly on CarriganArchives.org, establishing the .org as the permenant, active publishing home of The Carrigan Archives.

I did not set out to create an archive. There was no master plan. I simply wanted a place to share our work outside of social media. Two years later, the statistics are difficult even for me to believe. With hundreds of documented projects, it has grown into something much larger than I ever could have imagined.

The Archives is organized by substrate, town, service type, housing era, house style, type of damage, source of damage, room, materials, paints and primers, and evolving organizational infrastructure.

Instead of relying on large portfolios, we document real projects, real conditions, real repairs, and real results from homes throughout the Western New York suburbs.

Every article, project, photograph, and repair documented within The Carrigan Archives was written by the owner and founder of Carrigan Painting. No marketing agency. No ghostwriters. No AI created content. No photographers. No outsourced content team. Just real projects, one job at a time, documented by the same people who performed the work.

Visit The Carrigan Archives

Archive Timeline

2011

Created a company blog on Blogspot, and then totally forgot about it for 12 years..

July 2023

Began editing CarriganPainting.com with no prior website development experience.

Late 2023

Started taking large numbers of real project photos. Optimizing the photos became a thing.

December 2023

Rediscovered our original blog on blogspot and renamed it The Painter’s blog of WNY to explain project photos in more detail.

August 4, 2024

Moved the collection to dedicated hosting and officially launched The Carrigan Archives.

January 17, 2026

Registered CarriganArchives.org, giving The Archives its own official domain.

Fall of 2026

Began developing CarriganArchives.org as the permanent publishing home of The Carrigan Archives.

Archive Stats

As of August 2026:

180+

Articles & Records

150+

Documented Projects

200k+

Published Words

3,000+

Project Photos

1000+

Photos in Organized Galleries

50+

Project Videos

1

Author

Who We Work For

We are best suited for residential clients who understand that the quality of the repair is just as important as the final paint job. Many of our clients own older homes. They are not looking for the fastest, cheapest possible, painter. They are looking for someone who can explain the problem and fix it correctly so it doesn't come back.

We are also selective about the work we take on. That helps us stay focused on the types of projects where our skills are most useful. Interior work is where we are best suited.

In 16 years we have done a total of three (small) commercial projects.

  • English Park Village (Harris Hill) - 2013
  • The Wine Room next to Tops at Main & Union - 2015
  • The Local Edge - Getzville Campus - 2025
  • Reviews & Reputation

  • ✔ Reviews dating back to 2010
  • ✔ Perfect 5-star Google rating maintained for more than 16 years
  • ✔ Reviews preserved in our review archive
  • ✔ Reviews available on Google, Facebook, and Yellow Pages/SuperPages
  • ✔ No paid review services or automated review campaigns
  • We believe in acquiring reveiws organically. We have never used review software, paid review services, or automated review campaigns. All of our reviews were written by homeowners after their projects were completed.

    Because many of our clients are retirees and long-time homeowners, not everyone chooses to leave online reviews. As a result, our review count is lower than some larger companies, but the reviews we do receive span more than 16 years and come from real homeowners across Western New York.

    We maintain a permanent archive of our reviews as they existed at the end of 2025. This provides a historical snapshot of customer feedback and preserves reviews that may later be removed, edited, or become unavailable on third-party platforms.

    Local Awards

    Nextdoor Neighborhood Faves Award

    Winner of the Nextdoor Neighborhood 2024 & 2025 Faves Award

    5 stars, 16 years strong. Get Your Quote with Confidence